In 1966, a group of students at the University of Minnesota sat down to listen to a tape recording.
They were told it was an interview with a student trying out for his university's College Quiz Bowl team. On the tape, the candidate was asked 50 hard questions. He answered 92% of them correctly. He was modest about it, too, admitting that he had been an honours student, editor of the school yearbook and on the track team.
In other words, he was close to perfect.
Then, near the end of the interview, the listeners heard a clatter, the scrape of a chair, and a voice: "Oh my goodness, I've spilled coffee all over my new suit."
The students were then asked how much they liked him.
You might expect the spill to cost him something. A small embarrassment, a bit of lost polish. It did the opposite. The version of him who spilled the coffee was rated the most attractive and likeable person in the whole experiment.
The psychologist behind it, Elliot Aronson, called this the pratfall effect. Sixty years later, it may be the most useful piece of psychology a founder can know about building trust in public.
The twist nobody talks about
Here is the part of the study that usually gets left out, and it is the most important part.
Aronson didn't only record the brilliant candidate. He also recorded an ordinary one: a student who got 30% of the questions right, had average grades, was a proofreader on the yearbook and had tried out for the track team without making it.
And he spliced the very same coffee spill onto that tape too.
The results split in two directions:
| Candidate | Without the spill | With the spill |
|---|---|---|
| Highly competent (92% correct) | Liked | Liked most of all |
| Average (30% correct) | Liked less | Liked least of all |
The same clumsy moment made the expert more likeable and the average candidate less likeable. In the published paper (Aronson, Willerman and Floyd, 1966), the clumsy expert scored 30.2 on the combined liking scale. The clumsy average candidate scored minus 2.5.
So the pratfall effect is not "mistakes make you likeable". It is something more precise:
A small, human flaw makes people warm to you only after they already believe you are good at what you do.
That single condition changes how you should think about every honest, vulnerable or self-deprecating thing you share as a founder.
Why a flaw makes an expert easier to trust
Why would spilling coffee help anyone? Aronson's explanation still holds up well, and it maps neatly onto how buyers feel about founders.
Perfection creates distance. Someone who seems flawless is impressive, but they are also hard to relate to. We admire them from a distance. We don't feel we know them. A small slip closes that gap. It says: this person is brilliant, and they are human like me.
A flaw makes the rest of the story believable. When everything about a person or a company sounds perfect, part of our brain starts looking for the catch. An honest imperfection answers that question early. It makes the strengths feel real rather than polished.
Competence has to come first. For the average candidate, the spill confirmed what listeners already suspected: this person isn't quite on top of things. For the expert, it was a moment of humanity against a background of obvious ability. The same signal is read completely differently depending on what people already believe about you.
One honest note on the science. The 1966 study was small (48 students), and the boost for the expert, while clear in direction, was not statistically strong on its own. What made the study famous was the contrast between the two candidates. Later research, covered below, has refined when the effect works and when it doesn't. Treat it as a reliable pattern, not a magic trick.
For a founder, the practical point is this. Your audience first needs to see that you know your craft. Once they do, the honest, human moments you share stop looking like weakness and start looking like confidence.
Why founders hide their coffee spills
If small flaws help, why do so many founder profiles read like a press release? Every post is a win. Every client is delighted. Nothing ever went wrong.
A 2018 study helps explain it. Psychologists Anna Bruk, Sabine Scholl and Herbert Bless at the University of Mannheim ran seven studies on how people judge acts of vulnerability: admitting a mistake, asking for help, confessing feelings. In one, participants expected to improvise a song in front of a jury, either as the singer or as a jury member.
The finding was consistent. When people imagined showing vulnerability themselves, they saw it as weakness and a risk. When they watched someone else do exactly the same thing, they saw it as brave and positive. The researchers called this the beautiful mess effect: other people see our vulnerability far more kindly than we do.
The reason, they suggest, is distance. When it is our own mistake, we see every concrete, awkward detail. When it is someone else's, we see the bigger picture: here is a person being honest.
This is exactly what happens on LinkedIn. A founder drafts a post about a launch that flopped, imagines every reader judging her, and deletes it. Meanwhile, the readers she was worried about would probably have thought: finally, someone telling the truth.
Your fear of looking imperfect is, quite literally, a biased estimate.
When the pratfall backfires: four rules
The coffee spill is not a licence to overshare. The research points to four clear limits.
Rule 1: Earn competence first
This is the lesson of the average candidate. If your audience doesn't yet know you are good at what you do, an honest mistake doesn't humanise you; it confirms their doubts. On LinkedIn, that means your first posts to a new audience should show your thinking and your results. The "what I got wrong" post works best once people already trust your judgement.
Rule 2: Spill coffee, not the client's data
Aronson's candidate fumbled a cup, not a quiz answer. The flaw was small and had nothing to do with the skill being judged. A founder who admits she once misjudged a hire, or still can't keep her inbox under control, sounds human. An agency that admits it missed a client's launch date has a credibility problem, not a likeability win. Share flaws that sit beside your core promise, never ones that break it.
Rule 3: Don't fake it with a humblebrag
A humblebrag is a boast dressed up as a complaint or as modesty: "So exhausted from speaking at three conferences this week." It looks like a pratfall, but people see straight through it. In nine studies with hundreds of participants, Ovul Sezer, Francesca Gino and Michael Norton found that humblebraggers were liked and trusted less than people who simply bragged outright. A real pratfall costs you a little. A humblebrag costs you nothing, and audiences can tell.
Rule 4: Know who is watching
Not everyone responds the same way. A follow-up study by Aronson and colleagues in 1970 found that the observers' own self-esteem changed how they reacted to the clumsy expert: people with very high self-esteem were more likely to prefer the flawless version. In business terms, some audiences, such as a formal board or a regulator, may reward polish over warmth. Match the honesty to the room.
Using the pratfall in business
The same idea shows up well beyond coffee spills. Two later studies are especially useful for founders.
The broken chocolate bar. Researchers at Stanford and Tel Aviv University (Ein-Gar, Shiv and Tormala) tested what happens when you add one small negative to a list of positives. Students were offered chilled chocolate bars at half price on a hot day. When some were told the bars were also broken, the students who were busy or distracted, on their way into an exam, bought more, not less. The small blemish made the good points stand out. But students who were paying full attention preferred the purely positive pitch, and the effect disappeared when the negative came first.
That nuance matters. A LinkedIn feed is full of busy, half-distracted readers, so one honest limitation after your strengths can make a post more believable. A detailed proposal read carefully by a buyer is different: lead with clear strengths, and keep caveats factual.
"I'm sorry about the rain." In a field study at a train station on a rainy day, Alison Wood Brooks and colleagues had an actor ask strangers to borrow their phone. When he first said "I'm sorry about the rain!", 47% handed it over. Without that line, only 9% did. The apology wasn't for anything he had done. It simply showed he noticed how the other person felt, and that small act of empathy made him seem more trustworthy. (The field study was simple and had no proper control, so treat the exact numbers with care. The team's earlier studies in the same paper pointed the same way.)
How to use it on LinkedIn
Here is what this looks like in practice for a founder's content. (If you are building your presence from scratch, start with our guide on how founders can grow on LinkedIn.)
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| "Thrilled to announce another record quarter!" | "Record quarter. What nobody sees: we lost our two biggest pitches in July, and here's what we changed." |
| A polished list of five tips | Five tips, plus the one you ignored for years and paid for |
| "We've helped 100+ founders grow." | "We've helped many founders grow. The one thing we still find hard is ___, and here's how we're working on it." |
| Only posting wins | One honest "what I'd do differently" post for every three or four posts that show your expertise |
| Hiding the limits of your service | Saying plainly who you are not right for |
Three post formats that use the effect well:
- The lesson post. A specific mistake, what it cost, and the rule you now follow. The mistake is the hook; the rule is the expertise.
- The behind-the-curtain post. Show the messy middle of something that worked: the draft that failed, the meeting that went wrong, the plan you scrapped.
- The honest fit post. Explain who you are not the right partner for. It sounds risky, but it makes everything else you say about who you do help far more believable.
In every case, the flaw does a job. It makes your competence easier to believe.
The real lesson of the coffee spill
Sixty years on, Aronson's tape still says something most founders need to hear. People don't trust you because you are perfect. They trust you because you are clearly good at what you do and honest enough to show you are human.
Polish gets you admired. Honesty, shown at the right moment, gets you believed. And in a feed full of record quarters and flawless launches, the founder who admits the coffee went everywhere is often the one people remember.
So be excellent first. Then let people see the spill.
FAQ
What is the pratfall effect in simple terms?
It is the finding that a highly competent person becomes more likeable after a small, harmless mistake, while a less competent person becomes less likeable after the same mistake.
Who discovered the pratfall effect?
Social psychologist Elliot Aronson, with Ben Willerman and Joanne Floyd, in a 1966 study at the University of Minnesota.
Does admitting mistakes on LinkedIn really build trust?
It can, if your audience already sees your expertise and the mistake is small, specific and paired with what you learned. Without that, it can simply look like you don't know what you're doing.
What is the difference between a pratfall and a humblebrag?
A pratfall is a real, slightly costly admission. A humblebrag is a boast disguised as a complaint or as modesty. Research by Sezer, Gino and Norton found humblebraggers are liked and trusted less than people who brag openly.
Can a company use the pratfall effect, or only individuals?
Both. Brands can mention an honest limitation after their strengths, or say plainly who they are not right for. Keep the flaw away from your core promise.
How often should a founder share failures or lessons?
There is no fixed rule. A useful starting point is one honest lesson post for every three or four posts that show your expertise.
Want help finding your founder voice?
At GhostPen Studio we help founders and leadership teams build a LinkedIn presence that people trust: clear expertise, honest stories and a voice that sounds like you, not a press release. We also turn those stories into video and podcast content and social media that sounds like you. If you'd like to work out which of your stories are worth telling, let's talk.
— Harmandeep Kaur, Co-Founder & Brand Strategist, GhostPen Studio
Book a Discovery Call →Sources
- Aronson, E., Willerman, B. and Floyd, J. (1966), "The effect of a pratfall on increasing interpersonal attractiveness", Psychonomic Science 4(6): paper (PDF)
- Helmreich, R., Aronson, E. and LeFan, J. (1970), "To err is humanizing sometimes: Effects of self-esteem, ability, and a pratfall on interpersonal attraction", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 16(2)
- Bruk, A., Scholl, S. G. and Bless, H. (2018), "Beautiful mess effect: Self-other differences in evaluation of showing vulnerability", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology; summary (BPS Research Digest)
- Sezer, O., Gino, F. and Norton, M. I. (2018), "Humblebragging: A distinct and ineffective self-presentation strategy", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology; summary (Phys.org)
- Ein-Gar, D., Shiv, B. and Tormala, Z. L. (2012), "When blemishing leads to blossoming: The positive effect of negative information", Journal of Consumer Research 38(5); summary (Stanford GSB)
- Brooks, A. W., Dai, H. and Schweitzer, M. E. (2013), "I'm sorry about the rain! Superfluous apologies demonstrate empathic concern and increase trust", Social Psychological and Personality Science; summary (BPS Research Digest)